Sitting at a crowded oyster bar in Charleston one evening last winter, a friend slid a glossy Ross-Simons catalog across the table. She pointed at a three-stone ring with a price tag that felt like a typo. She asked if these 'too-good-to-be-true' prices on their engagement rings were actually legit, or if she was about to buy a very expensive piece of costume jewelry.
Quick heads up before we get into the weeds: there are affiliate links throughout this site. If you click and buy, I earn a commission at no extra cost to you. I only link to jewelers I’ve personally researched or visited in person, and believe me, my spreadsheet for this stuff is embarrassing. Full transparency is the only way I work.
I’ve been the 'ring person' in my friend group ever since my own 'spreadsheet phase.' You know the one—where you have fourteen tabs open comparing table percentages and depth ratios until your eyes blur. After helping a dozen friends navigate this, I’ve learned that Ross-Simons is a household name for sterling silver and Italian gold chains, but when it comes to the 'Big One'—the engagement ring—they are a bit of a wildcard. The distinct, heavy thud of a 300-page Ross-Simons catalog hitting a wooden coffee table, smelling faintly of high-gloss ink and perfume samples, is a nostalgic sound, but nostalgia doesn't guarantee a GIA-certified rock.
The Catalog Trap: Simulated vs. Lab-Grown
One Tuesday evening last January, I found myself deep in the Ross-Simons rabbit hole for a friend. I spent forty minutes trying to find the 'clarity' grade in a catalog’s fine print, only to realize the stone was a 'simulated' diamond, not a lab-grown one. It’s a classic move in the catalog world. They use terms like 'Diamond-Plus' or 'Cubic Zirconia' in very small font while the photography looks like a million bucks.
If you are looking for a forever stone, you need to know the difference. A diamond is a Mohs scale 10—the hardest mineral on earth. A 'simulated' stone is usually a 8 or 8.5. It will scratch. It will cloud. It’s fine for a cocktail ring you wear twice a year, but for something you’re wearing while doing dishes, lifting gym weights, or wrestling a toddler? It’s not going to last. If you want the real deal without the mined diamond price tag, I usually point people toward a lab-grown specialist like GOODSTONE instead, where the transparency is baked into the business model.
Gold Purity and the Manual Labor Reality
When it comes to the metal, Ross-Simons is generally honest. Most of their bridal pieces are 14-karat gold, which means the metal is 58.3% gold and the rest is alloy for strength. This is the industry standard for a reason. However, here is where my 'skeptical friend' alarm goes off: their settings are often very delicate.
This advice fails for couples who work manual labor jobs. If you’re a nurse, a chef, or someone who spends their weekends doing DIY projects, the thin, ornate bands Ross-Simons is famous for in their 'Estate Collection' might not hold up. I’ve noticed the slight squinting and neck tension that comes from holding a jeweler’s loupe to a 14k hallmark on a vintage band under a kitchen pendant light—sometimes those dainty prongs are just waiting to snag on a sweater and drop a stone. For a more robust daily driver, a brand with a massive physical footprint like Kay Jewelers often has heavier settings that can take a beating, plus the convenience of in-person repairs.
The 'Estate' Gamble and Certification Gaps
Ross-Simons loves their 'Estate' designation. In the jewelry world, 'Estate' just means previously owned. It doesn’t mean 'Antique' (which usually implies over 100 years old). It’s a great way to get a unique look, but the paperwork is often where they stumble. While modern specialists provide IGI or GIA reports by default, Ross-Simons often uses their own in-house 'Certificate of Authenticity.'
The Diamond 4Cs Glossary: Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat explained covers why this matters. If a stone isn't third-party certified, that 'G' color could easily be an 'I' in the eyes of a real gemologist. The FTC disclosure requirement says diamond weight must be accurate within 0.005 carats, but that doesn't help you if the clarity grade is three steps lower than advertised. My friend’s nervous laughter when I started reading the Ross-Simons 30-day return policy aloud at the dinner table to see if it covered 'change of heart' was a mood—you need that window if you realize the stone doesn't sparkle like the photo.
Comparing the Big Players
If you’re feeling nervous about a catalog purchase, you aren't alone. I’ve seen people start at Ross-Simons and end up at Zales because they wanted to actually see the stone before committing. You can read more about that in my breakdown of Is Zales a Good Place to Buy Engagement Rings for Beginners?.
Ross-Simons excels at the 'backup' ring or the travel ring—something that looks expensive but won't break your heart if it gets lost in a hotel pool. But for the primary engagement ring? You might want the personalized service of a boutique like Theo Grace. They offer a level of curation that a high-volume catalog company just can’t match. Last month, a coworker of mine was looking at a Ross-Simons solitaire, but after we did a side-by-side on the specs, she realized she could get a better-certified stone for nearly the same price by going to a dedicated diamond dealer.
The Verdict: Is It Good Quality?
Is Ross-Simons jewelry good quality? For fashion jewelry, gold chains, and fun 'Estate' earrings, absolutely. I have a couple of their pieces in my own jewelry box. But for an engagement ring, you have to be an obsessive note-taker. You have to check if the stone is 'simulated,' 'lab-grown,' or 'natural.' You have to check the return policy. And you have to be okay with the fact that you're likely getting a lower-tier stone than you'd find at a specialized bridal boutique.
If you are looking for a unique, vintage-style band and you have a jeweler on speed dial who can check the prongs for you, Ross-Simons can be a goldmine. Just don't let the glossy pages talk you out of your common sense. If you want a stone with a pedigree, stick to the specialists like GOODSTONE or the reliability of a major chain where you can walk in and yell at someone if a stone falls out. Your ring should be as solid as your relationship—and ideally, it shouldn't require a magnifying glass to find the truth in the fine print.